Perhaps government needs to develop a cooperative trusting relationship with amateur archaeologists?
Having followed some of the major treasure battles throughout the years and also based on some personal experience, it always amazes me that the “professionals” have passed laws that give them total ownership of the treasure hidden in the land and sea. And they have the power to pass the laws.
In the end, many important artifacts disappear from view with little of no proper analysis.
In the one instance, treasure hunters realize the problems they face when they do find something of value and the items are never claimed and enter the murky artifact underground.
In the second instance, the artifacts are collected and stored by government museums which, as this article highlights, do not have the resources to properly handle these artifacts let alone make them available to researchers and other interested parties that would benefit from access to the items and information.
So is there a solution? Of course there is. Solve the “turf” problem that many professionals subscribe to and then there is absolutely no reason why collected artifacts should not be registered with the jurisdictional body and retained by the finder with every right to sell or otherwise transfer ownership, provided the managing body was notified and within certain sensible guidelines. Additionally, small displays by individuals and organizations should be encouraged, particularly where they provide more understanding about the local area where they were uncovered.
Where to store a million artifacts? Nova Scotia’s past poses present problem – Nova Scotia – CBC News
Hundreds of thousands of artifacts make up the Nova Scotia Museum’s growing collection
By David Burke, CBC News Posted: Mar 15, 2017
A law devoted to the protection and study of historical sites in the province has created a dilemma for the Nova Scotia Museum: once an artifact has been unearthed, where on earth can it go? Nova Scotia’s Special Places Protection Act, introduced in 1989, makes it illegal for anyone to go hunting for archaeological artifacts without a heritage research permit. The same legislation also requires archaeologists to hand over whatever they find to the province once an area has been excavated and the items cannot be rejected.
That’s left the Nova Scotia Museum — one of the oldest provincial museums in the country — with a lot of history and little place to store it. “We’ve got well over 500,000 [artifacts] and I think we will be nearing a million before too long,” said Catherine Cottreau-Robins, the curator of archaeology for the museum, which consists of 28 sites across Nova Scotia.
Storage problems aren’t unique to the museum’s archaeology department. The museum’s department of cultural history routinely refuses donations that are similar to items it already has, including clothes, jewelry and antique tools.However, the archeology department cannot reject artifacts recovered through a heritage research permit, even if it already has multiples of the same object in its collection, said Cottreau-Robins. The exception is donations from the general public that are not deemed significant.
The number of permits to do archaeological work in the province has doubled in the last decade, meaning artifacts have been pouring in looking for a new home.
“We’re always thinking about space we’re filling up,” said Cottreau-Robins. Sean Weseloh-McKeane, the special places coordinator with the provincial Department of Communities, Culture and Heritage, said archaeologists at a dig site use their own discretion in deciding which artifacts should be removed.
“In some sites there may be large numbers of nails from the early 1900s. Do we need every single nail to come into the provincial collection? Probably not,” he said.
“The archaeologists are selecting the items that should be coming in to the provincial collection.”
Working on creative solutions
Many artifacts are housed at the Museum of Natural History in Halifax but the Nova Scotia Museum also stores items in facilities in Mount Uniacke and Stellarton. Many community museums also have artifacts on long-term loans. Most items need to be stored in climate-controlled environments. Cottreau-Robins couldn’t say how much it costs the museum to store artifacts because she doesn’t handle budgeting.
CBC News asked the Department of Communities, Culture and Heritage for an estimate of that cost, but did not receive a response.
Cottreau-Robins said she and her team are trying to come up with creative solutions for their growing storage problems. “There are challenges to it,” she said. “But that’s my job as a public servant to work on those challenges and come up with solutions … and find out what Nova Scotians want us to do about collections.”